Casa H fence markThe Ranch Wire
A Casa H Channel

Jewish man sues over alleged 2024 assault outside Manhattan Israeli restaurant

By Velvel Ranchman

· 4d ago

File photo: Tenth Avenue in Manhattan, Aug. 3, 2020; not a picture of the January 2024 assault or of HaSalon.
Photo: Eden, Janine and Jim via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

The National Jewish Advocacy Center, with support from StandWithUs, on Monday announced a federal civil-rights lawsuit it brought on behalf of Moshe Katz, who is Jewish and says he was punched unconscious outside a Manhattan Israeli restaurant after he said "Am Yisrael Chai." The center calls it an antisemitic assault.

The complaint was filed Sept. 2 in federal court in Manhattan and amended Oct. 26, JNS reported.

According to the complaint, shortly after midnight on Jan. 28, 2024, Katz was on the sidewalk outside HaSalon, at 735 Tenth Avenue, with Jewish friends. An Israeli flag was on display, and one person in the group wore a necklace bearing the Hebrew word "Chai."

Sami Bibovic and another man came up and asked if the restaurant was Israeli, the filing says. After someone in the group said that it was, the two men began making hostile remarks about Jews, Israelis and Israel, and an argument followed.

When Bibovic turned that language on Katz, Katz answered with "Am Yisrael Chai," meaning "the People of Israel live." Bibovic then punched him in the face with a closed fist and knocked him unconscious, the complaint alleges.

Katz suffered broken bones in his nose, cuts and a severe concussion, the advocacy center said, and nearly three years later he is still being treated for conditions he ties to the attack. The suit seeks damages under federal law and under New York's state and city civil-rights statutes, as well as for assault and battery, and asks for a jury trial.

Bibovic was prosecuted over the alleged assault before the suit was filed, and that criminal case ended within a year, according to the complaint as described by JNS. The filing does not say how the case was resolved.

"Jewish Americans do not have to accept violence as the price of living openly as Jews," said Alan H. Scheiner, the center's senior litigation counsel, in the group's announcement. Yael Lerman, who heads the Saidoff Law Division at StandWithUs, said civil court can offer a path when victims of antisemitic violence do not always get justice in the criminal courts.

— The Ranch Wire · A Casa H Channel

By Velvel Ranchman · The Ranch Wire

More in U.S.

All U.S.

Alerts

Short, sourced briefs.
On your phone.