Casa H fence markThe Ranch Wire
A Casa H Channel

NetChoice files federal suit over New York social-media mental-health labels

By Velvel Ranchman

· 5d ago

File photo: The Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse in Manhattan's Civic Center, Jan. 13, 2023; not a photograph of this month's filing.
Photo: Kidfly182 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

NetChoice, a technology trade association, has sued New York's attorney general in Manhattan federal court to stop a state law that would require certain social media services to show mental-health warning labels.

The complaint, NetChoice v. James, was filed Friday, Nov. 13, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York. It names Attorney General Letitia James, in her official capacity, as the defendant. Bloomberg Law also reported the filing.

The complaint identifies the statute as New York's Senate Bill 4505, later amended by Senate Bill 8827, and says that "beginning on January 1, 2027," covered operators must display the required label. Gov. Kathy Hochul signed the law, Yeshiva World News reported.

According to the complaint, the required label "shall contain the following text": "The Surgeon General has warned that while social media may have benefits for some young users, excessive use may be associated with significant mental health harms." The filing says the warning must be shown each day a user accesses a covered service, unless the service has "reasonably determined" the user is over 17, and that users cannot "bypass or click through the warning."

On first display, the complaint says, the label must remain for at least 10 seconds and occupy at least 25% of the screen. Once a user has reached three hours of cumulative active use, the label must appear again; from that point, once an hour, it must remain for at least 30 seconds and occupy at least 75% of the screen, the filing says.

The complaint says an "addictive feature," as the statute uses the term, means "an addictive feed, autoplay, and/or infinite scroll." It lists, "at a minimum," services from these NetChoice members as covered: YouTube; the TikTok companies named in the filing; SpaceXSI (X); Reddit; Pinterest; Meta (Facebook, Instagram, and Threads); and Automattic (Tumblr). Yeshiva World News described the plaintiff as a tech industry group whose members, it said, include Google, Meta and TikTok.

In a statement on Nov. 13, Paul Taske, director of the NetChoice Litigation Center, said: "The First Amendment forbids New York from forcing private speakers to serve as government mouthpieces, and that includes compelled state-scripted warnings on speech." He also said: "New York has every right to share its views on social media, but it has no right to make private websites say it for them."

The complaint says a federal court has already enjoined what it calls Colorado's "materially similar" warning requirement, in a case styled NetChoice v. Weiser.

— The Ranch Wire · A Casa H Channel

By Velvel Ranchman · The Ranch Wire

More in U.S.

All U.S.

Alerts

Short, sourced briefs.
On your phone.