Advocacy group sues New York City over Health Department's refusal to recognize Jewish staff group
· 5d ago

The National Jewish Advocacy Center has sued New York City, its Department of Health and Mental Hygiene and the department's equal employment opportunity director on behalf of seven Health Department employees, saying the agency refused to recognize a Jewish staff group while recognizing six other identity-based groups.
The complaint, filed November 10 in Manhattan federal court as Cohen v. City of New York, alleges the agency twice turned down recognition for a Jewish employee group called HINENU, and later opened what the filing calls a retaliatory inquiry into the group's leaders after they marked the murder of Jews at a Chanukah gathering.
The department runs an Employee Resource Group program that, the complaint says, supplies recognized groups with a $5,000 yearly budget, a SharePoint page, an agency email account, and a slot on the agency calendar. Officials rejected HINENU, the filing says, citing a claim that Jewish identity is "religious" and that "ERG identity cannot be based on religious groups." HINENU's charter, according to the complaint, described an association built around Jewish peoplehood, ancestry and culture, and said the group would stay out of worship, religious teaching and political advocacy.
Among the six employee groups already recognized, the complaint says, is one defined around the shared ancestry of the "indigenous peoples of Southwest Asia and North Africa," which, by that group's own charter, spans more than one religion.
The complaint alleges that after two gunmen killed Jews at a Chanukah celebration on Bondi Beach in Sydney, Australia, HINENU sent a mourning message to about 85 employees and held an online gathering for Jewish staff who were grieving. The department's equal employment opportunity director ordered the group to "desist" from using its email account, the complaint says, and later began an inquiry, lasting nearly four months, into eight HINENU leaders for "racial and religious discrimination."
Investigators questioned them about Zionism and Israel, according to the filing. The department closed that case in June 2026, saying it was "unable to make findings." Sixteen days later, the same official rejected HINENU's request for recognition in one sentence, pointing only to the group's alleged religious character, the complaint says.
The filing places those decisions in what it alleges has been a hostile atmosphere for Jews at the workplace since October 7, 2023, including a memo sent across a deputy commissioner's division on the "settler colonial establishment of Israel" and a recorded staff training in which a participant called the October 7 massacre "armed resistance," with no recorded objection. It also cites a lecture the agency sponsored at its headquarters.
An official who hosted that session told more than 100 attendees that the agency's "Global Oppression Working Group" had been "developed in response to the ongoing genocide in Palestine," the complaint says. The same official later became the principal complainant in the inquiry into the plaintiffs, according to the filing.
The complaint further alleges that the department's actions reflect a citywide policy of hostility toward Jewish peoplehood, pointing to Mayor Zohran Mamdani's attacks on Israel.
The plaintiffs, represented by NJAC attorney Alan H. Scheiner, ask the court to order the department to recognize HINENU just as it does the other resource groups and to clear the investigation from their records, and they seek compensatory and punitive damages. The claims are brought under Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, the city and state human-rights statutes, and the First and Fourteenth Amendments.
Scheiner, NJAC's senior litigation counsel, said in a statement: "The Jewish people should enjoy the same support and the same rights that are afforded by the law and the City to other ethnic and cultural groups. Here, a City agency has denied Jewish employees access to the same resources as other identity groups, and made its offices an unwelcome environment for any Jews who adhere to a fundamental element of their identity, which is the profound connection between members of the Jewish people and the people and state of Israel."
Mark Goldfeder, NJAC's chief executive, said: "The City told its Jewish employees that every identity counts except theirs, then investigated them for grieving. City Hall can hold whatever opinions it likes about the Jewish state; it cannot make hostility to the Jewish people a condition of working for New York."
— The Ranch Wire · A Casa H Channel