Verified class action in TWU suit challenges NYC's carriage-horse ban
· 2d ago

The Transport Workers Union's lawsuit over New York City's plan to end horse-drawn carriages is a verified class action filed Thursday in the Southern District of New York as Civil Action No. 26-cv-10154. The complaint asks for a declaration, an injunction and damages, and demands a jury trial.
The named union plaintiffs are John Chiarello, president of TWU Local 100, and John Samuelsen, the international president, along with a carriage medallion owner, a lessee and a licensed driver. The defendants are the city, the City Council, Mayor Zohran Mamdani and several agency commissioners. The plaintiffs are represented by Arthur Z. Schwartz and Benjamin J. Kallos.
The suit challenges Local Law 165 of 2026, also known as Int. 943-A, which the complaint says the Council named Romanch's Law. The complaint says carriage licenses and plates expire on May 31, 2028, and that the law requires no compensation.
In a statement, the union said the case argues that the ban violates rights under the United States Constitution and the New York State Constitution.
The suit was filed shortly after the mayor signed the bill. A spokesperson for the city's Law Department said the office is reviewing the case, the Associated Press reported.
— The Ranch Wire · A Casa H Channel